French Jazz Fans outsmart Hitler

Statue of Miles Davis by Niki de Saint Phalle in front of the Negresco hotel in Nice
Miles Davis statue – Negresco hotel in Nice.  Photo by Margo Lestz

France has a special place in its heart for jazz and in the summer, you’ll find jazz festivals all over the country. In fact, the world’s first international jazz festival was held in Nice, France in 1948. But France’s relationship with this music started some 30 years earlier during World War I and developed under some interesting circumstances during the Nazi Occupation of World War II.

Jazz comes to France
During World War I, African-American soldiers introduced France to jazz. After the war, this lively new sound was the perfect accompaniment to les années folles, or “the crazy years”, when all art forms were changing and tastes turned to the unconventional and exotic. This new African-American music made people feel alive again, just what was needed after the horrors of the First World War.

Hot Club
Jazz was especially appreciated by the young and in the early 1930s, a group of Parisian students formed a jazz club. At first they just met to listen to the music, but later they became ambassadors of this new sound. The Hot Club de France quickly grew into an important organisation working to promote jazz in France. Hugues Panassié was president and Charles Delaunay secretary, but in 1936 Louis Armstrong was elected Honorary President of the club and held that title until his death in 1971.

French Jazz
With the help of the Hot Club, jazz took root in post-war France. Although they appreciated the American jazz groups, the Hot Club was on the lookout for French talent. They “discovered” guitarist Django Reinhardt and violinist Stéphane Grappelli who, along with others, became known as the Hot Club Quintet, the first “all French” jazz band.

Django Reinhardt, French jazz guitarist
Django Reinhardt, French jazz guitarist

Jazz during the occupation
When the Second World War was declared, most of the African American jazz musicians left France and the French bands were worried. Hitler wasn’t a jazz fan. He considered it a tool of the Jews and detrimental to society.

But, Hitler was more tolerant in France than in other countries. He wanted to remain on good terms with the French and use their resources for his war effort. He also planned to make Paris a recreation centre for his troops so he encouraged the entertainment industry there. Foreign tunes were absolutely forbidden but he allowed traditional music, thinking his propaganda would be better accepted if it was broadcast along with popular songs.

“Frenchified” jazz
The Hot Club took advantage of this situation and set about creating a “French history” for jazz, proclaiming it a traditional French form of music. They held conferences explaining how jazz was directly inspired by Debussy, an influential French composer of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and circulated flyers detailing this invented pedigree.

They wrote books to convince Hitler and the Vichy regime of the merits of French jazz. One music critic published a book explaining how it was intrinsically French and how it could become the new European music under the Nazi regime. Hugues Panassié, president of the Hot Club, published a book addressing the Vichy regime’s argument that jazz couldn’t carry a patriotic message. In his book he claimed that jazz had simply been misunderstood and he scattered biblical passages and political quotes throughout to make it sound convincing.

Louis Armstrong disguised as a French man
Louis Armstrong disguised as a French man

It’s not swing, it’s jazz
Music experts pointed out that the jazz musicians of the time were all French (the American musicians had left at the start of the war) and they made “adjustments” to make jazz seem more French. At the time the music was called “swing” in France so they started calling it “jazz” which sounded less American.

It’s not blues, it’s tristesse
The titles of songs were changed to French: “St. Louis Blues” became “Tristesse de St. Louis” and “I Got Rhythm” became “Agate Rhythm”. The names of composers were either left off or changed. Louis Armstrong’s songs were credited to Jean Sablon during that time. When they had finished, jazz looked as French as baguettes and brie. Their efforts paid off when the Nazis banned subversive “American swing” but permitted traditional “French jazz”.  Of course, it was the same music, just cleverly repackaged.

Jazz and the Resistance
Hot Club members weren’t just defying the Nazis with music, many of them were active members of the Resistance. They used jazz concerts and conferences as cover to pass information to England. In 1943 the Hot Club headquarters in Paris was raided and some of its officials were arrested. Delaunay, Hot Club secretary, was released after one month, but several of the others perished in Nazi concentration camps.

However, jazz survived and kept the French company during the occupation. And when the war was over, France remained faithful to the music that, by that time, really had become woven into French culture.

Click on the video below to see Louis Armstrong learning a song in French with Claudine Panassié, daughter-in-law of Hugues Panassié, president of the Hot Club and director of the 1948 Nice Jazz Festival. It was filmed in 1969 at Armstrong’s home in Corona, New York.

History of the Nice Jazz Festival:

  • 1948 – Nice hosted the first international jazz festival in the world. Louis Armstrong was the headliner and performances were in the opera house and the municipal casino (which once stood in Place Massena).
  • 1972-1973 – The next jazz festival in Nice took place 23 years later. The performances were held in the garden Albert I.
  • 1974 – The Nice jazz festival returned under the name, Grande Parade du Jazz. Musicians played on three stages in the open spaces of the garden of Cimiez.  The Nice jazz festival has continued since 1974.Margo Curious Rambler Signature
  • 1994 – The name was changed to Nice Jazz Festival.
  • 2011 –  The festival moved back into the centre of town and to the garden Albert I where two stages welcome multiple performers each evening.

French Holidays & Traditions, Margo LestzOrder from AMAZON.COM
Order from AMAZON.CO.UK

Follow this blog

14 thoughts on “French Jazz Fans outsmart Hitler

    • Yes, it’s amazing that some people felt so strongly about the music that they would go to such lengths to be able to listen to it.
      Yes, you definitely must return!!! 🙂

      Like

  1. Brilliant video of Louis Armstrong repeating phonetically the French lyrics of C’est Mon Desir – humorous and heart-warming, considering the love and
    acceptance he found in France when Jim Crow was still prevalent in his home country.

    Like

    • Yes, I love this video too. Louis is so charming! It must have been such a culture shock to come to France and see a country where there were no “white only” restaurants or hotels. I imagine it was difficult to go back to the US after that.

      Like

  2. I am doing a research project on this topic, sort of An exploration into Jazz and its role during WW2/ the German Occupation in France, focusing, in particular, on its role as “aesthetics-as-politics” (the power of the arts to construct political ideas and thus make a political change). I am still struggling to find a particular issue/idea to focus on, just wondering if you have any advice for me? I was thinking of maybe looking into the lyrics of the popular songs? Thanks !

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hello, what an interesting topic! I don’t really know about the song lyrics, but Jazz did play, at least a small part, in the Resistance movement. I’ll send you a list of my sources by email and maybe you’ll find something interesting in there. Best of luck and keep me updated on your progress.
      Margo

      Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s