Did you know that the city of Nice, France almost had a 49 foot (15 meter) tall statue of the Virgin Mary standing atop the Colline du Chateau (Castle Hill)?
Nice Needs a Virgin
In the 1980s, the idea of the “Virgin on the hill” came to the Abbey Royal of Nice, who may have been inspired by the huge “Christ the Redeemer” statue that stands watch over the city of Rio de Janeiro.
The colossal Virgin Mary would be placed on the top of the Colline du Chateau (Castle Hill – where no castle actually exists) and would be facing out toward the sea. She would welcome those who approached Nice by boat much like the Statue of Liberty does in New York. Nice’s statue would be called Notre Dame de la Baie des Anges (Notre Dame of the Bay of Angels).
The abbey went to see the mayor, Jacques Médecin, who agreed that it was a brilliant idea. However, because of the French laws separating church and state, the giant virgin couldn’t be built with state or city funds. If she was to be, the people of Nice would have to fork over the money. The two men had high hopes of public support and thought the project could start in November 1983 and be finished by February 1988.
Preliminary drawings were done, and the local newspaper published them along with an invitation to the public to give their views. The people responded with their comments, both positive and negative. They thought the face of the Virgin was charming and they liked the idea that people could go up into the statue and look out over the sea, much like in the Statue of Liberty.
But then, the newspaper published the view from the back, the part of the statue that much of the city would be seeing. People were not happy to see an exterior elevator shaft running up the folds in the back of the Virgin’s skirt. And, even worse, it entered the statue at a point which caused many readers to question whether she was really a virgin…
After five years of debate, the plan was abandoned and the Niçois contented themselves with their original, tried and true heroine, Catherine Ségurane, who had gained fame by chasing off the Turkish army using pretty much the same part of her anatomy.
Further reading: Catherine Segurane and The Apollo Statue
- Les Dessous de la Côte by Christian Gallo, 2008, page 15
- Nice Matin, 31 mai, 2015
Follow Me – If you would like to keep up with my articles, you can receive an email every time I post (every other week or so). Just enter your email below and click the Follow the Curious Rambler button.
- Beatrix Potter: Mushrooms, Bunnies, and Sheep - 1 March 2023
- Lovelorn Seek Help from Juliet and Beatrice - 12 February 2023
- Wassailing: Blessing the Apple Trees - 1 February 2023
Funny story! Who would’ve guessed that elevator shaft could be so contentious? I wonder whether there is any shadowy history around the virgin on the Fourvière cathedral overlooking Lyon…?
Well, you just have to be careful where you put those shafts… You should look into the history of the Lyon Virgin – maybe there is a story there too, who knows.
Hi. I’m not there right now. Traveling for another week. Hopefully next time!
This is really amusing as well as interesting. It had not occurred to me that separation of church and state could cause problems with statues of the Virgin. #AllAboutFranace
Thanks. Apparently, the State doesn’t mind if there are large religious monuments, they just won’t pay for them. It makes sense to me.
So funny! Fancy being shafted by an elevator! I’d not heard this story before, thanks for sharing it Margo. #AllAboutFrance
It sounds very painful, doesn’t it? 🙂
Thanks for sharing this story!! I hadn’t heard about this. I really enjoy your writing style 🙂
Thank you so much. I’m glad you enjoyed it.
As always – an interesting and funny story. Do you think Christ the Redeemer has the same problem? Pretty sure he doesn’t or we’d have heard about it.
You’re right, there is no elevator in the Rio statue – just an interior staircase used for maintenance and not open to the public. I did find an interesting fact, though, it seems the plaster moulds for the head and hand of the statue came directly from France, where the sculptor Paul Landowski lived.
Love that picture of the fountain! Made me smile 🙂
Sometimes we just need to look at things from a different angle! 🙂